Live on EWTN

The closing Mass for the Fortnight for Freedom is underway and may be viewed on EWTN on TV or internet.

The Mass began on July 4th, noon EDT.

Update: Cardinal Wuerl’s homily follows.

Four years ago I had the privilege and joy of participating in an event in southern Maryland that tells a story that we need to hear again today when we commemorate the Fourth of July, our nation’s independence, and our freedom as citizens of this great country.

With pageantry and prayerful ceremony, hundreds of people gathered at the reconstructed 1667 Brick Chapel in historic Saint Mary’s City, Maryland, for an unusual event. The sheriff of Saint Mary’s County, using an exact reproduction of what is arguably the very key that his predecessor used to seal the chapel in 1704, unlocked its tall, sturdy wooden doors. Together with representatives of the Jesuit community in Maryland, I had the privilege of pushing open the doors.

The unlocking, while a symbolic or ceremonial event, carried with it great significance because it was a reminder that we are a free people and among the rights we celebrate are freedom of conscience and freedom of worship. But it also recalled that our own freedoms are fragile and easily compromised.

In 1634 when the Ark and the Dove arrived, carrying nearly 150 English settlers to what is now Saint Mary’s County, those brave women and men established the first settlement to guarantee religious liberty to all of the inhabitants. In effect, they constructed what would become known as the birthplace of religious freedom in America.

All of us, as spiritual descendants of those intrepid women and men, can rejoice and take pride in their vision and courage.

Unfortunately, in 1704, when those who did not share this foresight and Catholic perspective gained political control, they revoked the freedom of religion in the colony. They found it more convenient to silence the Church — even with force — than to live in peace with her and her Gospel message. The Royal Governor ordered the brick chapel locked and never again used for religious purposes. The Jesuits later dismantled the chapel and used its bricks to construct a manor house at the Saint Inigoes Mission.
The story of the rebuilding of the Brick Chapel is an intriguing narrative in itself. Despite the efforts to silence the Church, the early Catholics in Maryland persevered. Three centuries later we celebrated a visible, tangible testimony to an inalienable right — our inherent human right to religious liberty and the blessing of freedom of conscience.
Today we Catholics from all backgrounds and walks of life gather at the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in our nation’s capital for the closing Mass of the Fortnight for Freedom.

I can think of no better way for us to end our second nationwide Fortnight of Freedom than to come together, to stand together, and to pray together, in thanksgiving for our God-given gift of religious freedom, enshrined in the “First Freedom” in the United States Constitution’s Bill of Rights.

On July 4 we mark Independence Day, our nation’s birthday, a special time to remember and celebrate who we are as Americans. We recall that on this date in 1776 our founding charter, our Declaration of Independence, was signed. Here in our nation’s capital we can visit the National Archives and see this remarkable statement which includes the unforgettable phrase, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.”

From the beginning of our nation the founders recognized our equality and liberty, and that those rights were bestowed on us by God.

As our first reading today from the Book of Genesis tells us, God created all things and established the order of creation including the unique role of human beings — men and women created in the image and likeness of God.

After the nation’s bicentennial, a monument to the 56 signers of the Declaration of Independence was dedicated near the Lincoln Memorial’s Reflecting Pool. Carved in stone are replicas of each signature, along with the signer’s name, occupation and hometown and state. These men represented all walks of life and backgrounds. They were lawyers, merchants, physicians, farm owners and surveyors. Benjamin Franklin of Pennsylvania was a printer and scientist. Charles Carroll of Carrollton, a Marylander and the only Catholic signer of the Declaration, was a merchant and farmer. Lyman Hall of Georgia was a physician and Congregationalist minister.

These signers professed many different faiths. They were Catholic, Congregationalist, Deist, Episcopalian, Presbyterian, Quaker and Unitarian. From many different backgrounds, representing many religions, they stood united for liberty.

Over the centuries since that decision to lock the Brick Chapel, our struggle for liberty, the Declaration of Independence and our Revolutionary War, we have all recognized the importance of religious faith in a free and democratic society.

Even today in the context of a secular world, the quiet, soft and gentle voice of the Spirit has not been stilled. It continues to speak to human hearts. Not by bread alone do we live.

The second reading for today taken from the Letter of Paul to the Ephesians reminds us that we must not “grieve the Holy Spirit of God with which you were sealed.”
We must always be open to the promptings of the Spirit. Our commitment to religious liberty, to human freedom, to our faith, does not rest on our individual resolve or limited resources. The First Letter of Saint Peter reminds us, “You have been born anew, not from perishable but from imperishable seed, through the living and the abiding word of God” (1 Pet 1:23).

The celebration of the unlocking of the Brick Chapel is the recognition of the place of values — moral, ethical and religious — in life and in the society of which we are a formative part.

As the key turned in the lock and the doors swung open, we were all provided an opportunity to reflect that sadly there are still those who think that the best way to deal with opposing opinions, differing views, moral perspectives and ethical imperatives is through force.

Closer to our day, we see another tactic. The Church is denounced as prejudiced, narrow-minded or even un-American simply because her teaching respects human life, upholds marriage and calls for health care for the most needy in our country.

In March, just across town, we witnessed an example of the new intolerance, the new form of locking doors. At George Washington University an effort was made to silence the Catholic chaplain and to “lockout” his ministry to Catholic students and faculty just because he taught those who freely came to Mass what Jesus said about marriage.
And so, here we are.

The idea that the pastor of a parish today or the chaplain of a religious community or campus ministry today should simply be silenced because he faithfully announces the Gospel of Jesus Christ — that he should not be allowed to engage in dialogue with our culture, even in a place that is dedicated to the free and diverse expression of ideas — may seem somewhat radical today, but you have to remember there have always been those who try to force their views on all of us. There have always been those who want to lock doors so the voice of the Gospel cannot be heard.

When we talk about marriage, when we speak about the dignity of human life, when we teach about the natural moral order, we are lifting up elements that we find deeply rooted in the consciousness of the Judeo-Christian tradition. Just because someone wants to change all of that today does not mean that the rest of us no longer have a place in this society.

Remember after someone says you cannot speak here, then comes the sentence, “And you do not belong here.” Our response must be the response of Jesus Christ, the response of his Church, a response rooted in love.

The Gospel chosen for today reminds us that Jesus calls us to follow his invitation to love one another and to accept this challenge as the norm for our way of living.
When others use force, there will always be the temptation to respond in kind. But we must respond out of who we are. We are followers of Jesus Christ. We speak the truth in love.

Again, in the second reading, Saint Paul tells us, “So be imitators of God, as beloved children, and live in love.”

To speak out against any form of discrimination, social injustice or the redefinition of marriage, marital relations, or threats to the dignity of life is not to force values upon our society, but rather to call our society to its own, long-accepted moral principles and commitment to defend basic human rights.

The celebration at historic Saint Mary’s City was a tribute to the triumph of the human spirit over adversity and the ultimate victory of truth. But it was also a reminder that there are always those with a key ready to close us out of the public forum and our rightful and legitimate place in the debates over what is good public policy.

The beautiful fall afternoon ceremony of the unlocking of the Brick Chapel was not just a revisiting of history but, in fact, a study of current events.

In January 2012, Pope Benedict XVI explained to United States bishops in Rome the challenge to our culture of a “radical secularism which finds increasing expression in the political and cultural spheres.” He went on to highlight “of particular concern are certain attempts being made to limit that most cherished of American freedoms, the freedom of religion…The seriousness of these threats needs to be clearly appreciated at every level of ecclesial life.”

The Holy Father’s answer to this “radical secularism” and “denial of rights” is, as he explained, “an engaged, articulate and well-formed Catholic laity endowed with a strong critical sense vis-à-vis the dominant culture and with the courage to counter a reductive secularism.” And here you are!

Your faith is a remedy for what ails our society. The mission of all of us, but particularly of the laity is to engage the culture with the Good News that only comes from Jesus Christ.

This may seem daunting, but remember, we are a people of hope. It is why Blessed John Paul II called for the New Evangelization and why Pope Benedict XVI carried this call into the new millennium, and why Pope Francis is such an example of living faith with courage and serenity. We know that while we must still defend our freedom, Christ has already won the final victory.

In a moment, we will celebrate Holy Mass. At each Mass, we remember and celebrate who we are as Catholics. We gather around the table of the Lord to receive the gift of the Eucharist, just as the Apostles gathered around Jesus at the Last Supper. The Paschal Mystery of Jesus’ suffering, death on the cross and Resurrection is made real to us, here and now, and then we go out to the world to share that gift of Jesus’ new life and his love.

That new life in Christ, that living out of our faith, is reflected not only in our worship and in our personal acts of charity, but in our Church’s educational, health care and social ministry outreach. Those works, those acts of faith, are threatened whenever our religious freedom is eroded.

Before I elevate the consecrated host and the chalice of Jesus’ blood, we are all on our knees together. Let us thank our Lord for the gift of life and for the freedom to love and worship our God. Pray that through the power of the Holy Spirit we may be his witnesses.

In the presence of our Lord we will kneel. There is a time to be on one’s knees. There is also a time when we need to stand — to stand up.

Some time ago I was invited to give an invocation at a public event attended by hundreds and hundreds of people. The prayer was to follow the presentation of the flag and the singing of the Star Spangled Banner.

From behind the curtain on stage where I stood, I could see the young man who sat with a console on his lap controlling the light and sound mechanisms for the hall. He also had in his hand the script to tell him when to dim the lights and what microphones to turn on.
As the flag was brought in and the singer intoned the Star Spangled Banner, all of the people in the audience stood. Behind the curtain and seen by no one but me, the young man, trying to balance the console, the lights, the sound system and his script, attempted to stand. Clearly, even though no one saw him, the national anthem meant enough to him that he wanted to stand up.

Pray also for the courage boldly and joyfully to stand in protection of our freedom so that we may continue to live out our faith and transform the world in which we live.
Today there are things that should mean enough to all of us, including our religious liberty, that we simply need to stand — to stand up for what is right, to stand up for what is ours, to stand up for freedom of religion.

Let us thank God for the call, the freedom and the courage to stand up for religious liberty.

The Mass Form and the Scripture

PrayTell has entered the debate over whether the new or old form of the Roman Rite has more scripture. But as the comment box illustrates, much of the answer turns on the music: are we singing propers with Psalms or replacing propers with hymns with invented words? Also, the old form is seriously subsidized in its scriptural references by prayers at the front and back of Mass that have since been trimmed. There is a case to be made either way, and I would even question the baseline assumption that more is always better. In the end, it is the praxis that matters most here: are we choosing the options that permit the liturgy to be heard or are we imposing another layer on top of it?  

Requiescat in pace

The world of Christian music lost one of its great teachers this past Monday, July 1.

Bert Polman was chair of the music department at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and a senior fellow for the Calvin Institute of Christian Worship.

I attended a summer workshop on hymnology led by Dr. Polman several years ago, which brought together musicians in higher education for an intensive week of study. We were given many tools for developing and hymnology curricula. But much more importantly, we were given a fresh perspective. Hymns come from Psalms. (Dr. Polman said the Genevan Psalter was his life’s blood.) Psalms sing of lamentation as well as praise. True hymns sing of God.

A great teacher meets students where they are and sets their sights further down the road in fruitful directions. While we learned as much as we could in a week, thousands of lucky students learned over the course of years, with humor and zeal.

Please remember Dr. Polman in your prayers.

Music uploads from the Colloquium 2013 are live!

Take the day off and listen. Complete list is here.

Mass in English, Ordinary Form
11th Sunday of Ordinary Time
Tuesday, June 18
Rev Robert Pasley, celebrant
David Hughes, organist

1 Prelude Intermezzo, JA 66, Jehan Alain David Hughes 6:21
2 Introit Hearken, O Lord, unto my voice, mode iv Ryan 2:06
3 Kyrie Missal 0:37
4 First Reading Janet Gorbitz 3:22
5 Psalm Praise the Lord, my soul, mode vii Morse 1:59
6 Alleluia I give you a new commandment, mode ii Ryan 1:09
7 Gospel 1:31
8 Prayers of the faithful Missal 1:59
9 Offertory I will bless the Lord, mode i Mahrt 2:39
10 Motet at Offertory Honour and Majesty, Maurice Greene Buchholz 1:38
11 Sanctus Missal 0:45
12 Memorial acclamation Missal 0:22
13 The Lord’s Prayer Missal 1:38
14 Agnus Dei Missal 0:51
15 Communion One thing have I asked, mode vii Morse 5:22
16 Motet at Communion O for a Closer Walk With God, Charles Villiers Stanford Buchholz 3:42
17 Recessional When in Our Music God Is Glorified, Stanford 3:27
18 Postlude Joie et clarité des corps glorieux
Les Corps Glorieux, Olivier Messiaen
David Hughes 8:33

Organ Recital
Charles Cole
Tuesday, June 18

1 Ballo della battaglia Bernardo Storace (fl. 1664)
2 Felix namque Anonymous (c. 1520)
3 Fugue in E flat (St. Anne) BWV 5552 J.S. Bach (1685 – 1750)
4 Méditation (from “Suite Médievale”) Jean Langlais (1907 – 1991)
5 Salve Regina (with sung chant alternatim) Olivier Latry (1962 – )
6 Rorate Caeli
Attende Domine
(from “12 Chorale Preludes on Gregorian Chant Themes”)
Jeanne Demessieux (1921 – 1968)
7 Te Deum Jeanne Demessieux (1921 – 1968)

Compline
Tuesday, June 18

Compline 20:47

Lauds
Wednesday, June 19

Full Recording 20:53

Mass in English, Ordinary Form
Wednesday, June 19
Abp Alexander Sample, Celebrant
Jonathan Ryan, organist
Propers by Bruce Ford

1 Prelude Rhapsody in D-flat Major, Op. 17, No. 1, Herbert Howells Jonathan Ryan 7:06
2 Processional ? 2:27
3 Introit Hearken to my voice, O Lord, mode iv Hughes 3:51
4 Kyrie Mass XII, alternatem 1:38
5 First reading 2:00
6 Gradual Behold, O God, our defender, mode v Mahrt 2:23
7 Alleluia The king rejoices, mode vi Morse 3:06
8 Gospel 2:36
9 Homily Archbishop Alexander K Sample 9:02
10 Offertory I will bless the Lord, mode i Hughes 1:34
11 Motet at Offertory Ave, Maria, Edward Elgar Glenn 2:40
12 Organ interlude ? Jonathan Ryan 2:32
13 Sanctus Mass XII 1:20
14 Pater noster 1:54
15 Agnus Dei Mass XII 1:14
16 Communion One thing have I asked of the Lord, mode i Hughes 2:37
17 Motet at Communion O quam suavis est, William Byrd Brouwers 5:06
18 Recessional and Postlude Flourish for an Occasion, William Harris Jonathan Ryan 4:52

Lauds
Thursday, June 20

Full Recording 22:48

Requiem Mass in Latin, Extraordinary Form
Msgr Andrew Wadsworth, celebrant
Thursday, June 20

1 Introit Requiem aeternam, Francisco Guerrero Brouwers 4:42
2 Kyrie Missa pro defunctis, Guerrero Brouwers 2:06
3 Gradual Requiem aeternam, Guerrero Brouwers 4:09
4 Tract Absolve Domine, Guerrero Brouwers 1:52
5 Sequence Dies irae, mode i alternatim 6:20
6 Offertory Domine Jesu Christe, Guerrero Buchholz 4:34
7 Motet ? 2:02
8 Sanctus Missa pro defunctis Buchholz 2:45
9 Benedictus ? 1:14
10 Agnus Dei Missa pro defunctis Buchholz 3:26
11 Communion Lux aeterna, Guerrero Glenn 1:53
12 Motet at Communion O salutaris, Pierre de la Rue Malinka 3:48
13 Homily 9:03
14 At the absolution Libera me, Guerrero Glenn 8:33

Lauds
Friday, June 21

Full Recording 22:10

Memorial of St. Aloysius Gonzaga, Religious, Extraordinary form
Friday, June 21
David Hughes, organist

1 Prelude 5:46
2 Processional 2:41
3 Introit Minuisti eum, mode iii Ryan 2:33
4 Kyrie Mass VII 3:50
5 Gloria Mass VII 3:11
6 First reading 1:08
7 Gradual Domine spes mea, mode v Donelson 2:30
8 Alleluia Beatus quem elegisti, mode iii Schaefer 2:37
9 Gospel 2:53
10 Organ interlude 1 2:11
11 Homily 10:12
12 Offertory Quis ascendet, mode iii Mahrt 1:22
13 Organ interlude 2 5:12
14 Sanctus Mass VII 1:59
15 Agnus Dei Mass VII 1:37
16 Communion Panem caeli, mode viii Morse 0:51
17 Organ interlude 3 9:27
18 Postlude 10:06

Vespers, Extraordinary Form
Friday, June 21
Ann Labounsky, organist

These tracks run continuously, with no gaps.
1 Prelude Three versets on Iste Confessor, Jean Titelouze 5:41
2 Processional 1:54
3 Opening Versicle 0:43
4 Organ interlude 1 0:22
5 First antiphon Domine probasti me, mode iii; first psalm, 138.I, tone 3.g2 Mahrt 3:31
6 Organ interlude 2 0:46
7 Second antiphon Mirabilia, mode vi; second psalm, 138.II, tone 6.F Hughes 3:41
8 Organ interlude 3 0:50
9 Third antiphon Ne derelinquas me, mode iv; third psalm, 139, tone 4.E Mahrt 4:17
10 Organ interlude 4 0:42
11 Fourth antiphon Domine clamavi ad te, mode viii; fourth psalm, 140, tone 8.c Hughes 3:19
12 Organ interlude 5 1:04
13 Fifth antiphon Educ de custodia, mode iii; fifth psalm, 141, tone 3.a Mahrt 3:26
14 Chapter Beatus vir qui inventus est 0:32
15 Organ interlude 6 0:30
16 Hymn Iste confessor, Tomás Luis de Victoria Buchholz 5:06
17 Versicle Justum deduxit 0:22
18 Organ interlude 7 0:12
19 Magnificat antiphon Hic vir, despiciens mundum, mode viii 0:27
20 Magnificat octavi toni Jean Mouton  Buchholz 11:09
21 Magnificat antiphon repeated 0:27
22 Collect 0:57
23 Dismissal 0:34
24 Organ interlude 8 0:48
25 Salve Regina, mode i 2:45
26 Postlude Offertoire sur les Grands Jeux, Nicolas de Grigny 9:17

Lauds
Saturday, June 22

Full recording 17:52

Votive Mass of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Ordinary form
Saturday, June 22
Rev Jonathan Gaspar, celebrant
Jonathan Ryan, organist

1 Prelude Toccata in E Major, BWV 566, Johann Sebastian Bach 11:24
2 Processional 1:25
3 Introit Salve sancta parens, mode ii Morse 2:50
4 Kyrie Missa osculetur me, Orlando di Lasso Brouwers & Glenn 2:30
5 Gloria Missa osculetur me Brouwers & Glenn 4:31
6 First reading 1:37
7 Gradual Benedicta, mode iv Schaefer 4:23
8 Alleluia Post partum, mode iv Hughes 2:39
9 Gospel 1:24
10 Homily 8:30
11 Offertory Ave Maria, mode viii Mahrt 5:54
12 Sanctus Missa osculetur me Brouwers & Glenn 2:46
13 Agnus Dei Missa osculetur me Brouwers & Glenn 4:55
14 Communion Beata viscera, mode i Donelson 5:08
15 Communion motet Ave Maria, Sergei Rachmaninoff Buchholz 2:50
16 Recessional Ave maris stella, chant alternatim 3:22
17 Postlude Fugue super Magnificat, BWV 733, J. S. Bach 4:20

Lauds
Sunday, June 23

Full recording 16:34

12th Sunday of the Year (Year C), Ordinary form
Sunday, June 23, 11:00 AM
Msgr Joseph Mayo, celebrant
Doug O’Neill, organist

1 Prelude Toccata XI, Georg Muffat 5:44
2 Processional ? 1:18
3 Introit Dominus fortitudo plebis suae, mode ii Brouwers 3:39
4 Kyrie Mass of the English Martyrs, Jeff Ostrowski 0:53
5 Gloria Mass of the English Martyrs 2:17
6 First reading Richard Chonak 1:13
7 Gradual Convertere Domine, mode v Hughes 3:15
8 Second reading 1:11
9 Alleluia In te Domine speravi, mode iii Mahrt 3:12
10 Gospel 1:56
11 Homily Monsignor Joseph Mayo 12:01
12 Credo III 4:18
13 Prayers of the faithful Missal 2:47
14 Offertory Perfice gressus meos, mode iv Ryan 4:35
15 Motet at Offertory Ave Maria . . . benedicta tu, Josquin des Prez Glenn 3:05
16 Sanctus Mass of the English Martyrs 0:38
17 Mystery of Faith Mass of the English Martyrs 0:22
18 The Lord’s Prayer Missal 2:20
19 Agnus Dei Mass of the English Martyrs 0:49
20 Communion Qui vult venire post me, mode i Cole 3:25
21 Communion motet O Jesu Christe, Jacquet de Berchem Malinka 2:10
22 Communion motet O sacrum convivium, Luca Marenzio Buchholz 3:37
23 Hymn of Praise Take Up Your Cross, Bourbon 2:42
24 Recessional Laudate Dominum, Michael DeSaye Hughes 4:37
25 Postlude Toccata XII, Muffat
5:06

New Compositions
Tuesday through Saturday

Note: These compositions may have copyright restrictions; contact the composer for information!

The extended recordings include discussion and commentary before and after the songs.  Songs may have been edited to find the best take or combine together segments.

Lectures, homilies and lessons

Monday, June 17
Remarks at opening dinner, including Prof. Mahrt’s address 1:14:34
Veni Creator Spiritus 3:07
Tuesday, June 18
Life-long Learning: Personal Reflections on the Influence of the Liturgy Msgr Andrew Wadsworth 53:57
Wednesday, June 19
Plenary Lecture
   Written Transcript
Archbishop Alexander K. Sample 1:01:09
Thursday, June 20
The Art of Effortless Singing Dr Mee Ae Cecilia Nam 57:45
Friday, June 21
Gregorian Chant as the splendor formae of the Liturgy Dr William Mahrt 58:32/td>
Saturday, June 22
Sunday, June 23
Closing Remarks at Brunch 18:19

Breakout sessions

Wed June 19 Leading Dedicated and Enthusiastic Volunteers
Detailed notes
Recording of the discussion (33:36)
Carl Dierschow

Other random bits

Benediction as a Community Event

I was truly taken aback last night. I thought I was attending a quiet and small Benediction service last night at St. Isidore, Grand Rapids, a parish I had never been too. I walked in to find 300 plus people packed in for the event. It was truly beautiful and holy in every way. It ended with a talk by Fr. Robert Sirico on religious freedom and received a wild ovation (clapping is ok when the liturgy is over!).

In any case, this is a very pretty parish and I was just so touched to experience such an outpouring of desire on the part of this community to practice their faith. Imagine so many people choosing to spend their Tuesday night this way! Also, it was not only an older crowd. Whole families were packed into the pews, and plenty of teens without adults too.

I want to make special mention of a wonderful priest I met afterwards. He is in residence at St. Isidore. His name is Fr. George Fekete. He serves the parish but he is retired. He is 83 years old. At the social after, he bounded over to me and said “I hear you are a musician! Praise God that you are offering your talents to the holy faith!”

I was truly startled at his energy and enthusiasm. He has these deep blue eyes that seem to be searching for content to extract from the world and process in his mind. His mind works on overdrive too, like a young teenager without hangups. He is an absolute delight to speak with because his speech pattern has these unexpected periods of bursting energy that settles down again before its bursts again — like adulations of a song. Apparently he says morning Mass every day for this parish. I can just imagine how essential he is to this community.

As I looked at him and his happiness, and his completely unspoiled way of viewing the world, I thought: “this man is one of the best walking advertisements for the priesthood I’ve ever met.”

Sacra Liturgia 2013 and the Transformation of Traditionalism

A conference like Sacra Liturgia 2013, from which I have just returned, is the kind of thing that arguably could never have taken place during the Jubilee year of 2000 when I entered the seminary in Rome.  In fact, it could not have been conceived of even in the wake of the election of Joseph Ratzinger to the throne of St Peter in 2005, just before I was ordained to the priesthood.  I was reminded of just how much things have changed when I went this week early in the morning to St Peter’s to offer Holy Mass.
During my Roman years, which was really not all that long ago in a Church that thinks in centuries, I could easily walk into St Peter’s, and a few side altars would be busy at 7am with some few priests, mostly Vatican types or pilgrims, offering the Novus Ordo Mass in various languages.  Every once in a while you could spot the Latin edition of the Missale Romanum 2002, but not very often.  To even speak of the Missale di San Pio Quinto was to invite a reaction which could quite possibly result in expulsion from the Basilica of the Prince of the Apostles.  Sure, there were a few brave souls who had the indult who would produce a Missal from within their cassock pocket, but always with the Missal on the left side, and without altar cards, and fudging the rubrics just enough not to get caught.
You can imagine my surprise when I went this time.  The sacristy of St Peter’s, which used to be so delightfully quiet on an early weekday morning, is now a hive of activity.  Priests and pilgrims from all over the world find themselves at every single usable altar of the Basilica.  Altar cards adorn several altars in the North Transept, and one can see several of the Pope’s ceremonieri and other Vatican officials going back and forth from those altars celebrating Holy Mass in the classical Roman rite.  More than once I had to wait for an altar, and some priests eventually gave up after waiting in line for more than 2 hours to say Mass.  (Private Masses have a very small window of time in the Basilica, and either you get it in between 7 and 9am or you don’t!)
There were celebrations all over the Basilica, in various languages and uses of the Roman Rite, and in Latin in Ordinary and Extraordinary Forms.  Many of the kids from the Preseminario San Pio X have now learned to serve the Extraordinary Form, which some of them call, irony of ironies, la Messa nuova.  And the queue for the altars reserved for the Extraordinary Form was so long one morning I just gave up and celebrated Mass in Italian.
In the principal church of Christendom, Pope Benedict’s vision of liturgical pluralism had taken root.  There were no more suspicious glances, clerical catfights or mutual recriminations.  In fact, the spirit of peace and energy that now reigns over St Peter’s on weekday mornings was also very much evident at the Pontifical University Santa Croce this week for Sacra Liturgia 2013.
I cannot for the life of me imagine such a conference being held even a short time ago, at least outside of a dingy ballroom in a minor city with little interest and with some unsavory characters around.  But this event attracted not only first-rate liturgists, hierarchs and theologians, but also many laypeople, many of them very young, who were eager to learn and network with other people all over the world who had caught on to Pope Benedict’s vision.  And of course, there was the presence of the gliteratti of that new grand salon, the Blogosphere, and the knowledge that every thought, word and deed of the conference was going to reach an audience that it would never have reached before, merely because of advances in technology in service of tradition.
But what was even more amazing than the quality of the speakers at the conference, which I could go on about at length, and the beauty of the liturgies, which were celebrated in both forms, was the spirit which animated it all.  A conference which focused so much on the traditional liturgy once upon a time not so long ago would have been the preserve of people who have been caricurated, pilloried and described, sometimes not entirely inaccurately, as rigid, reactionary and schismatic.  Now, there are some in the Church today who still have not grown up quite past employing this paradigm for any and every who darken the door of a Mass celebrated according to certain books.  But the atmosphere at Sacra Liturgia 2013 was not like that at all.
While there was the occasional barb at liturgical looniness, it was directed, not in the service of a critique borne from a desire to paint the Liturgical Reform as a Masonic plot to destroy the Church, but from a desire to highlight a proper ars celebrandi.  And those barbs, few in number, were directed, not only against some of the most bizarre incarnations of the Novus Ordo, but also the hurried, hapless celebrations of the 1962 Missal and the psychopathologies of some who think that traditional Catholicism is a matter of dressing like the Amish.  Overwhelmingly, the tone was positive.  How can the entire Church develop a liturgical spirit via a beautiful ars celebrandi for the salvation of souls and the regeneration of society?  One of the most arresting things I took away from the Conference was the idea that ars celebrandi is not just a matter of externals to which the priest must attend, but a spiritual and theological orientation of the entire Christian assembly. 
I must confess that, going to the conference, I wondered whether some of the participants and speakers might see it as a “last hurrah” for the Benedictine liturgical party within the Church, and that it might be seen by its critics as the swan song for the Benedictine reform.  I wondered whether we might lose time and energy in harsh denunciations of the liturgical practices of Pope Francis, and turn on each other in division and hatred.
Nothing could be further from the truth.   This was a group which truly “thought with the Church”, not in a slavish manner, but as free men and women of God.  We were able to raise serious questions about the liturgical reform without having them turn into gripe sessions or anticlerical bashes.  There was a profound experience of communion, conviviality, prayer and study. 
Why is this important?  Well, I think that it is representative of what has happened in the Church because of the Pope in whose honor the conference was called.  There are many people who have discovered the beauty of the liturgy conceived, not in restrictive terms as saying the black and doing the red of one particular Missal, but in terms of an ars celebrandi which respects legitimate diversity.  A traditionalism which looks only backwards, and only with an eye to criticism, while it may contain some elements of merit with which the Church must dialogue, will eventually run out of steam.  But love for the liturgy, for God, for the Church and her shepherds, which is the ultimate goal, not only of various traditionalisms, but of Tradition itself, cannot stop at that.  The Conference was proof that traditional liturgy has a powerful dynamism for reform and renewal when it is unshackled from the tired labellings and trench warfare of the past.  The sheer diversity of the speakers and participants also point to the fact that the good insights of the traditionalists can be brought in medio Ecclesiae and transform the dialogue over the nature of the Church and her worship in a way which is not tied to the past, but can do good for the future.  Far from being critical of Pope Francis, a traditionalism freed from being tied into the critique of Vatican II and crisis rhetoric, embued with a spirit of communion and the spirit of the liturgy, shares in the desire of the Bishop of Rome for the Church to reflect Christ ever more.
Those for whom liturgy is not a battle to be fought over and won by texts and rubrics, but an enchanting participation hic et nunc in the divine life, will anxiously look forward to the publication to the Acts of Sacra Liturgia 2013.  There they will grasp a coherent vision of the Church’s life and worship which has, thanks to Pope Benedict XVI, transcended this tumultous time and its wars and opened up a way for the Church, not just towards the future, but towards the final consummation of all things in Jesus Christ.