Magister: Here We Go Again

Sandro Magister, who might be a wonderful journalist in some ways but who knows absolutely nothing about music and so he becomes vulnerable to being manipulated by his blustering contacts in the Vatican, is at it again, slamming the director of the Sistine Chapel choir. You are welcome to read his rant.

But notice this sentence: “It is not enough, in fact, that the selection of composers and songs is today more in line with the desires of the pope.”

Hold on a minute there buddy. What it means is that the SisChap choir has embraced B16’s musical desires. And that’s not enough for Magister?

I’m sorry but we’ve been down the road before. Magister is playing politics in the well-known way of this world. He has a horse in this race — Bartolucci will be grumpy and disgruntled until the end of time — and he is using his column to push for the one on which he placed his bet.

It is an indisputable fact that the music at the Basilica in general is VASTLY better than at any point in half a century. They are singing the propers in chant, real Gregorian, and often the music you hear in the Basilica is wonderful, particularly the chant. This has not been true in our lifetimes!! What’s more, no more goofy visiting choirs that sing American pop music. That was an incredibly gutsy move that ended decades of noisy corruption. Can we please give some credit where it is due?

As for the SisChap choir, the problem there appears to go back to the beginnings of the paleolithic period. No news here. Not even PX could fix this problem.

I took apart the last column by Magister on this subject, and don’t much feeling like doing it yet again.

Embrace the World of Sacred Music

Just about every Catholic I know is interested in this idea of re-introducing sacred music in their parish. The musical conventions are worn and tired, no longer fresh as they might have seemed when they came along decades ago. Meanwhile, there is all this vast amount of sacred music that has been sitting on the shelf, waiting to be incorporated into Mass. The trouble is finding the inspiration and means to make the change and doing so with some degree of competence and knowledge about what the change really means.

There really are no shortcuts to a thorough experience such as what the Sacred Music Colloquium provides. You can find out more at musicasacra.com/colloquium.

This year it run June 25 through July 1. It is being held in Salt Lake City at this city’s stunning cathedral. It is a full week of teaching, lectures, training, socializing, and participating in a liturgical life that is hardly available anywhere else. All your questions will be answered. You will discover the theological rationale. You will learn to read and sing chant. You will discover how polyphonic music fits in with sacred music.

In some ways, it is like learning a new aesthetic language. This requires rethinking the purposes and culture of Catholic liturgy itself. This program makes doing so fun, enlightening, and even life changing.

This year we are trying something new. We are trying to make the conference a friendly environment for people who do not think of themselves as musicians. For those who don’t want to sing complex polyphonic Masses, they do not have to. There are several beginning classes on chant that face no pressure to perform at any point in the week. You can just be in the classes and learn.

A major advantage of the venue this year is that it is very family friendly. Spouses, even those without the slightest interest in singing, can come and enjoy large parts of the program, attending the lectures and events they want to attend and otherwise enjoying the amenities of this great city.

In the past, the colloquium did actually require a commitment to attending rehearsals all day. For those who want to do this, that’s great. Nothing has changed. But for others who want to attend chant classes just to gain an exposure, attend the day’s liturgy to experience something amazing, go to a dinner or an afternoon lecture, those are available without the expectation that it will be “all music, all the time.”

At the same time, we’ve changed the program so that professional musicians feel very much at home. They can come to be with colleagues, attend one of many break-out sessions on a topic of their choice, or go to concerts of the best performers. They can spend time with the top experts who make up the faculty. This change was made because we are ever more aware that a large community is developing now and it includes people who are very sophisticated and sing chant and sacred music every week.

It is no small feat to put on this program at all — and the CMAA is a volunteer organization with a tiny and vulnerable budget (please support us: we need it!). It is even more of a trick to put together a program that serves beginners, professionals, and just interested attendees. But with much thought, time, and attention to lessons learned from past years, we think we have accomplished that this year.

As for the effectiveness of the program, it is beyond doubt. People are left changed by it. To live in and breath this culture for a solid week leaves a permanent mark. You come to realize just how remarkable the opportunity for beautiful liturgy really is. Every week when we forgo it in favor of something else is a week when sung prayer does not happen, and when, in a literal sense, an important part of the Church’s liturgy is left to languish. On the other hand, there is no one who cannot immediately understand the merit of true liturgical music upon hearing it.

There are many reasons why some people choose not to attend an event like this. There are those who think “I’m not a musician” and so they decline. This can no longer be an excuse. I’m thinking in particular of pastors and priests who are fascinated by the prospect of improved liturgy but don’t see how they fit into the picture. This time, they can come and learn so much and take this knowledge back with them to inspire change.

Also, there is often a confusion about the kind of people who inhabit the world of sacred music. The caricature is that we are snooty, stuffy, distant, dogmatic, and do nothing but sneer at popular music and every amateur attempt to do music at the parish level. This perception — and I’m not even sure what it is based on — is incredibly and wildly wrong.

Contrary to the caricature, the people who love this music are fun, warm, engaging people. There is no room for intellectual snobbery here because the chant itself is humbling — and not one attendee or faculty member knows all that he or she should or could know. There is a real sense in which we are all discovering this wonderful music together.

Nor is there an entrenched loathing of popular music on display at this event. Most of the musicians have sung other styles. We’ve played in jazz bands, rock bands, and sung every kind of music one can imagine. What makes the difference is that we’ve come to to realize that liturgy itself requires something special and unique — something “set apart.” The music especially suited for liturgy is unlike any other music in the world, with its own beautiful and own purpose. Once we discover that beauty and purpose, we fall in love with what could be, and we work hard to see it realized.

Once discovering chant, we don’t suddenly become stern and cold, disapproving of the state of the world and all that it is in. Sometimes the opposite happens. Sacred music is so fulfilling that we become more fun, more joyful about life, more liberally minded, more expansive in our outlook. To discover this music is like discovering a new sector of life itself, like learning philosophy or travelling to a new country that helps you see the whole world in a new way.

Another point here: it is not the case that an event like this preaches only one approach to music at liturgy. Every year the options grow. There are now so many varieties of chant, so many different ways to sing it, so many options for singing the liturgical text, so many beautiful choices that are presented before us. What makes the difference is that sacred music is using the actually liturgical texts and doing so in a balanced way that doesn’t exaggerate one truth (e.g., the people should participate in singing) at the expense of other truths (there really is an exclusive role for the choir!).

Many Catholic musicians I know (and actually this applies to many Catholics in general) are seeking inspiration and liturgical goals. We have a new translation of the Missal. What is next? Or is our experience at Mass just going to be the “same old” forever and ever? Sacred music provides a fresh start, something new and dazzling that helps us understand our faith and its liturgical presentation in a whole new way.

If you have ever considered coming to an event that deals with Catholic music, it is very likely that you are being called. Answer that call, and come to the Sacred Music Colloquium, June 25-July 1, 2012, in Salt Lake City, Utah. It is more exciting than any adventure you have ever experienced. This conference is for you, and it is only left to you to take that step.

Propers once a year…progress (I guess)

From the latest Pastoral Music as published by NPM:

“We all know the description of liturgical music’s importance from the Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy Sacrosanctum Concilium (SC): ‘The musical tradition of the universal Church is a treasure of inestimable value, greater even than that of any other art. The main reason for this pre-eminence is that, as sacred song united to the words, it forms a necessary or integral part of the solemn liturgy’ (SC, 112). But how have we appropriated that description of ‘sacred song united to the words . . . of the solemn liturgy’?

“Consider this example from the Chrism Mass: Diocesan liturgies often are unique, once-a-year (or even once-in-a-lifetime) events. They have particular needs and often require a specific repertoire. For example, the appointed text for the procession with the oils at the Chrism Mass is ‘O Redeemer.’ This text has no other liturgical use, but when done at the Chrism Mass its rich text helps reveal another layer of the mystery of the sacraments.

“Now while ‘O Redeemer’ may never be sung in a parish, this model of using specific (proper) texts from the Roman Missal or the Gradual can be of great benefit, for this processional hymn indeed weds the sacred song and the words of the liturgy. We have tended to get away from the ‘propers’ (texts assigned to specific days or liturgical actions), yet these can aid the people’s participation.

“If you have gotten away from using proper texts, consider following the cathedral’s example and add one or two a year. Chants for these texts can be found in a variety of sources (in both Latin and English), or they may be sung to another musical setting. The onees that seem easiest to find for congregation or choir (or a combination of the two) occur during Holy Week–Palm Sunday’s ‘Hosanna to the Son of David,’ Holy Thursday’s ‘Mandatum novum’ (‘I give you a new commandment’), the Good Friday reproaches, or the sequence on Easter Sunday. You’ll be surprised how much easier (and beloved) these become as you return to them year after year.”

Musica Sacra Florida, Now Is the Time

The registration deadline for the 4th Annual Musica Sacra Florida Gregorian Chant conference is this Friday, March 30th.

If you haven’t registered yet, find out more and register.

You and your choir are cordially invited to attend the 4th annual Musica Sacra Florida Gregorian Chant Conference, to be held at Ave Maria University on April 13th and 14th. This year’s conference will have two new features.

First, there will be more intensive workshops on the following subjects:
* Semiology (Study of the ancient chant notation)
* Chironomy (Gregorian chant conducting)
* Chant in English
* Church documents on sacred music, and history of sacred music in the 20th century
Second, both forms of the Mass will be offered:
* Latin Mass in the Extraordinary Form
* English Mass in the Ordinary Form
Participants will get to sing Latin and/or English chant in the closing Mass of the conference, which will be on Saturday, April 14th, at 5pm. This will be an anticipated Sunday Mass for the 2nd Sunday of Easter (Divine Mercy Sunday).

The conference is open to musicians, clergy, and parishioners. All are welcome!

News From the Front


I know that it has been a long time since I have made a contribution to Chant Café. But I continue to check in every day on what is going on in the chant world! One of the amazing things of changing gears from academic life to pastoral life is seeing how the things we discuss on blogs such as Chant Café as desirable actually translate into the life of the parishes.

I just wanted to share what we have been doing at my new parish, Prince of Peace, since I arrived in December, and would love to hear your feedback on similar things in your parishes as well. Check us out at www.princeofpeacetaylors.net.

I arrived in the new parish just as the new translation was getting underway. We have been using the ICEL Missal chants for the Ordinary, except for the Gloria, which we are doing according to John Lee’s new version. We are talking about using Schubert’s Deutsche Messe according to the new ICEL texts for the summer. And I am anxiously awaiting the Canons Regular of St John Cantius’ new ICEL version of Healy Willan’s Missa Sancta Maria Magdalena. I just found, however, in the 1960 something Hymnal a version which we can use, with the Kyrie, Sanctus and Agnus already new ICEL-compliant.

We have started to use the Chabanel Psalms, which have been lovely, and at the 10am Solemn Mass we have been doing the Simple English Propers for the Entrance, Offertory and Communion.

The church building is very unique: it is a modern interpretation of Romanesque, so it has some interesting challenges: a very, very high roof with a butler building ceiling, unpolished concrete floors, and not a right angle in the building. The Choirs are up in the gallery, and there is a large digital organ, which makes some impressive sound for such a large space.

Even though the organ has been virtually silenced for Lent, we have been having everything from Gabrieli to Vierne, so the people are getting quite a taste of some excellent organ repertoire. Improvisations on hymn tunes and chant pieces have become a regular feature of our worship.

The weekly School Mass has evolved as a teaching tool for the Reform of the Reform. We have a Novus Ordo Solemn Mass every Wednesday morning. We have not introduced propers yet, but the same hymns are sung which will be sung the following Sunday at Mass. We also are doing the Latin chant Ordinaries associated with the liturgical seasons, and the kids have been doing very well learning Mass XVII for Lent. While everything at the Sedilia and Ambo is in English, everything at the Altar is in Latin. I taught the kids all of the sung parts of the Latin OF as well as the responses from the Orate fratres forward. And the kids have learned to tell the difference between an ictus, an episema and a quilisma. They really like the quilisma for some reason.

The parish had the Extraordinary Form every Sunday for about seven years, and we are now doing it every day at Noon. The Sunday Mass is a Missa Cantata at noon, right after the 10am English Solemn Mass. So singing two high masses in a row with incense makes for a grueling task for me and the musicians, but it is something to see our very tall church, with its numerous glass windows, replete with heavy clouds of incense every Sunday!

After a seven week sermon series on the sacred liturgy at the EF Mass, the Curate and I have been doing an Adult Education series on following Latin Mass and Vespers. While our EF congregation (which numbers anywhere between 150-200 each Sunday, as opposed to up to 1000 people at the 10am Mass) for some reason is still reticent to sing much at Mass (they love listening to the Schola), they are all about Vespers. We will begin Sunday Vespers and Benediction in Paschaltide, alternating men and women in the congregation, and the 30 or so people who have been coming to the classes are doing a fine job of struggling their way through Vespers. I am amazed at how quickly they have caught on! We always do the seasonal Marian Antiphon after the EF Mass.

Some time ago I was approached by the Director of Music who said that some of the kids from the High School Youth Group wanted to sing at the Sunday evening Last Chance Mass. I was skeptical, fearing that they wanted some kind of Christian Rock/Lifeteen thing. Imagine my surprise when they debuted as a Choir singing Kevin Allen’s Desidero mi Jesu, and sounded better than the college music majors we have on as Choral Scholars at the Solemn Mass!

We have added a lot to the musical program already existing in the parish. We did a Latin Missa Cantata for the Purification sung by a men’s schola entirely in chant and an English Mass for St Joseph with the Litany of St Joseph from the Cantus selecti in procession to the Parish Hall.

Holy Week is coming. Orlando Gibbons and Palestrina for Palm Sunday along with the chant music. Josquin des Prez’ Missa Pange lingua for Maundy Thursday with Durufle’s Ubi caritas and Tantum ergo by Bruckner. And we are already planning for Corpus Christi, with a Procession with lots of fun music.

Of course, all of this is possible because of the leadership over thirteen years of my predecessor, Msgr Steven Brovey, who introduced both Reform of the Reform and Extraordinary Form ideas into Upstate South Carolina when it was still considered a no-no. The music team of Alan Reed and Dewitt Tipton has been phenomenal, and continues to be so. The only thing I regret is losing the irreplaceable Loraine Schneider, who taught the Ward Method in our parish school and is now at Holy Rood in New York, on to bigger and better things.

I love sharing all of this, because we are a 1200 family (more or less) parish in the buckle of the Bible Belt in South Carolina. We are an ordinary suburban parish with ordinary people, a debt of $1,000,000 from the building of a now 8 year old church. There has been some small outflow of parishioners not amenable to the liturgical culture of the parish, but there has also been an amazing outpouring of generosity of current parishioners and new ones who have chosen Prince of Peace. And this in a small Southern city that has other fine liturgically centered churches as well! I am proud to be the shepherd of such a church. A parish modeled on Pope Benedict XVI’s vision for the sacred liturgy and music is possible. If we can do it down in South Carolina in an ordinary parish with ordinary people, it can be done in other places as well. I would be fascinated to hear how your parishes are coming along with the re-enchantment of the sacred!

http://youtu.be/5ge89fKM5O8 Check out a video from our Solemn Midnight Mass for Christmas done by one of our friends!